Politicians have been named as the least trusted people on St Helena, along with journalists.
But the governor has come second in a list of the most distrusted people on the island – and that fact was left out of a summary of the findings that was issued to media by the government.
Governor Mark Capes is not named in the report on the first-ever survey of ethics at work, and it is possible the distrust relates to governors in general.
Only 74 people said they trusted the governor, despite the fact that 70 people who responded described themselves as senior managers or leaders, and 320 (73%) worked for the government.
Councillors were “not trusted” by a massive 60% of respondents. The governor was distrusted by 39%, closely followed by journalists (38%), police (35%), doctors (33%) and business leaders (32%).
Another 32% said they did trust doctors – and 36% offered no opinion.
But the summary issued to the media only mentioned a different set of findings –showing the people who came bottom of a list of “trusted” people.
It said only 9% of people trusted councillors, followed by journalists (14%) and business leaders (18%).
It failed to mention that the governor – the unelected representative of Her Majesty the Queen, appointed by Britain’s Foreign and Commonwealth Office – came fourth from the bottom, trusted by only 19% of respondents.
The survey was conducted by the Institute of Business Ethics, a UK charity. It pointed out that journalists and politicians also rank low in British surveys of trusted figures.
St Helena Government has been asked to explain why the findings for the governor were not included in the summary issued to the media – especially as it says that “honesty is defined as… speaking the truth”.
In response, it said only: “Both reports are openly available in the public domain. We have nothing to add.”
The initial press release did say that the full report had been published on the government website. The list of trusted figures is on page 33 of the document.
It shows the most trusted people are teachers (54%), followed by technical professionals and skilled labourers (42% each) and religious leaders (41%).
The summary says: “Councillors, business leaders and journalists were shown to be the least trusted professions.
“This could partly be due to the fact that these professions are linked to key decisions made for the island at this time of change and are relatively high profile figures.
“Of course, it could be that a particular councillor, business leader or journalist is not trusted.”
The distrust of the governor may also be historic, relating to various governors who have served in recent years.
However, the St Helena Freedom of Information Campaign has argued that the excessive secrecy practised within The Castle has caused deep distrust of the island’s government.
And the dealings of the main decision-making body, the executive council, have become more secretive under Governor Mark Capes.
His reports of ExCo meetings are also far less revealing than those of his predecessor, Andrew Gurr, who made sure parts of ExCo meetings were routinely open to the public.
Governor Capes has challenged the island’s new legislative council “to improve the reputation and worth of councillors in the eyes of the people of this island”.
Newly-elected executive councillors are working on ways to improve openness – and increase trust. But it is expected to take time to change a deep-rooted culture of secretiveness in The Castle.
A team from the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association, led by Lord Shutt of Greenock, arrived on St Helena on Tuesday 31 July 2013 to help councillors be more effective.
An unofficial briefing seen by St Helena Online says that councillors have been over-reliant on advice from senior officials in the past, because of a lack of support systems enjoyed by politicians in larger democracies.
Public servants were trusted by only 25% of people in the ethics survey, and distrusted by 24%. However, 73% of those surveyed were… public servants.