St Helena Online

St Helena Online

The St Helena report and the gap in media

Communist Tristan da Cunha? That’s like waving a red flag…

Sharing is caring!

The potato patches aren’t exactly a gulag, and the closest similarity to the Berlin Wall is that its buildings get blown down in storms… but Tristan da Cunha has been described, by its former governor, as a communist state. In the nicest possible way, of course.

Andrew Gurr was paying a compliment to the 260-or-so people of the world’s most remote inhabited island when he made his observation, but it’s raised the eyebrows of one seasoned Tristan watcher.

Mr Gurr told this site: “Tristan is a successful example of communism and I really stand by that.

“I think that for me, they just pull together in a way you wouldn’t expect in a society that was much bigger.”

His original comments can be seen here, in a transcript from his talk in Oxford in May 2012 to the Friends of St Helena.

A reader has responded by quoting Wikipedia:

“Communism is a revolutionary socialist movement to create a classless, moneyless, and stateless social order structured upon common ownership of the means of production.”

Leaving aside the bit about money, it’s that common-ownership bit that spoils the analogy, says our reader:

“While Tristan has a great deal of communal ownership, and everyone is pretty much provided for equally, the primary means of production is the fish factory… which is owned by a South African company.”

SEE ALSO:
The inside story on St Helena, by former governor Andrew Gurr
Tristan’s ‘Mr Fix-It’ turns 65 – but will Joe really retire?


Share your comments here

Sharing is caring!

You might also enjoy

error: This content is protected !!
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription to St Helena Online has been successful.

St Helena Online Newsletter

Subscribe to our news and stay updated.

Please like or share

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter